HR demands employee quit their job after they submit a 79-page report about entitled boss's lack of management, which HR claims lacks proof: ‘I’m talking to a lawyer’

Author image for Bar Mor Hazut
Bar Mor Hazut • Senior Editor
Dec 18, 2025 7:00 AM EST

Many employees learn the hard way that HR is not their friend, and they care much more about protecting the company and management than the average employee. They might sing a different tune, going on and on about wanting to help and be there to listen to any complaint, then as soon as one dares to voice a complaint, HR immediately shows their true face.

When the employee in the story below collected evidence about their boss's poor management, they were sure HR would be in their corner. They spend months collecting screenshots and recording handbook violations that would prove just how badly their boss is performing. They then reported it to HR and hoped they would do their job.

Instead, the employee was met with radio silence, an empty calendar, and their work assigned to someone else. Not only did HR not help, but they actually made things worse for the employee. It was so bad that the employee didn't have a choice but to resign. 

And guess who got to keep their job without any repercussions?

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • Cheezburger Image 10587477760
    via shironosov

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Reported boss to HR, investigation concluded with my termination

    Throwaway account, but I've been lurking here for months, and this sub helped keep me sane.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Context: medium- sized tech company in the U.S. I was there ~9 months (since April), terminated this past Friday.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I'm a mid-30s woman in a senior IC role. I'm unfortunately very familiar with disordered personalities, mostly from my personal life, but I'd never encountered one this severe at work.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I'd also never gone to HR in my career until this experience. My boss (Nboss) hired me and kept me on a pedestal for the first ~5 months.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • The company is mostly remote, so I had limited informal contact with colleagues early on. In late August, after a small restructure, a peer with the same title but a different manager was moved under Nboss.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • She immediately asked to meet privately and told me she was nervous, asking how to "stay on her good side." That was my first hint that a bad side existed.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Soon after, we had an in-person offsite where I bonded with colleagues. Several warned me that Nboss had a reputation for blindsiding reports with surprise 30-day PIPS.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • The person I replaced had been treated like a punching bag, PIP'd, and fired on day 30.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I was shocked but grateful for the context. Not long after, the mask came off. During a stressful project retro, I gave calm, constructive feedback.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Nboss snapped and accused me of not being able to take feedback (pure projection). From then on, she told others I was "difficult" and couldn't handle feedback.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I've never been described this way by any other colleague or past manager. Nboss is the insecure, sadistic type who picks a target and uses them as a punching bag.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Her boss (VP/my skip-level) is a charismatic, grandiose narc. I clocked the Cluster B from VP very early, and believe they functioned as a team, with VP shielding Nboss and enabling her behavior.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • While my relationship with Nboss deteriorated, my peer assumed the role of punching bag. She was blindsided with a 30-day PIP after 2 months under Nboss, following 6 years at the company with only positive reviews from her previous manager.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • The "issues" cited were absurd (e.g., typos). She was overloaded with impossible work and clearly set up to fail.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • While this was happening, I was assigned a leadership presentation. I did exactly what Nboss asked, did a dry run with her the day before, and she approved it.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • During the live presentation, she interrupted me in front of leadership and said, "You should have done a dry run with me first." It was deeply humiliating and felt like a setup; others later corroborated this.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • This was a "final straw" moment for me where I decided enough was enough. That weekend, I documented everything: months of gaslighting, shifting expectations, isolation.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I ended up submitting a 79-page report, 70+ screenshots, and 60+ handbook violations. This timing coincided with a disastrous Team Health survey, where Nboss's domain scored worst by far on management-related questions.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • After my report and the alarming survey results, my peer on the flimsy PIP submitted a formal report to HR as well.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • HR assigned a brand-new HRBP who initially seemed supportive and launched a 3-week investigation. Meanwhile, I continued documenting: being excluded from meetings, underutilized, isolated, while the "golden child" with the same title had full access.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I raised concerns with VP about being excluded from meetings and feeling like I was being isolated.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • She claimed it was a cost-cutting measure to keep headcount low, and that I could watch recordings of the Zoom calls at 1.5x speed to "save the company money".
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • My work requires heavy collaboration and asking questions, so this excuse was ludicrous. I also requested a manager change.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Cheezburger Image 10587477504
    via Tima Miroshnichenko

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • She said yes and suggested revisiting after Thanksgiving. I went on PTO the week after Thanksgiving, felt amazing, and knew HR was interviewing colleagues whose answers corroborated my report.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I felt cautiously optimistic. I returned to work to radio silence: empty calendar, my work reassigned to someone else.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Also, my role was listed online and I saw that VP was interviewing candidates. I documented further exclusion and disparate treatment.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • When Friday morning rolled around, I emailed HR with a brief update and 13 pages of additional documentation showing retaliation and worsening isolation since filing my report.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Minutes later, I was pulled into a Zoom with HRBP and VP. Both were cold. HR said the investigation found nothing to substantiate my claims.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • was given two options: 1. Stay at the company under a PIP overseen by Nboss 2.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • Mutual separation agreement with severance Given Nboss's track record with PIPS, the choice was obvious. I negotiated more severance, then was locked out of Slack, email, and systems while still on the call.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I haven't signed the agreement yet (I have 7 days). I'm talking to a lawyer to see if the ultimatum is either retaliation (option 1, the PIP) or constructive dismissal (option 2), though this is really not in my nature.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I'm also wondering whether I can push for more severance in the eleventh hour. Immediately after my exit, my peer was fired outright - no severance before her 30-day PIP even ended.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • They said her firing was based on performance and not her HR report. I'm more at peace now than when I was in the holding pattern, but I'm shaken by how speaking up in good faith led to this outcome.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • I'm more heartbroken for my peer, who gave six loyal years, than I am for myself.
    via Fresh_Session9029
  • If you've read this far, thank you. This community helped me stay grounded when I needed it most.
    via Fresh_Session9029

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boss employee fired hr manager job toxic boss tales-from-the-workplace overworked-employees workplace company report
Scroll Down For The Next Article